Logo image
Applying Definitions of the "Rule of Law" to Shakespeare's Measure for Measure
Journal article   Open access   Peer reviewed

Applying Definitions of the "Rule of Law" to Shakespeare's Measure for Measure

Raj Bhala
Vol.19(2), p.286
11/15/2026

Abstract

Rule of Law Measure for Measure Comparative Literature Jurisprudence Law Shakespeare
William Shakespeare’s Measure for Measure (1604) is all about the rule of law. From beginning to end, the play presents both secular and sacred legal issues, their interplay, and the trade-offs that can and do arise in the everyday lives of everyone on stage, reading the text, or viewing the drama. This article identifies and analyzes the legal and related moral problems of – not by accident – the only play the Bard of Avon (1564-1616) titles after a Biblical passage (namely, in Chapter 6, Verse 38, of The Gospel According to Luke). (This said, as to Shakespeare’s The Tempest, note “tempest” is mentioned in various Biblical passages, including New Testament accounts in Matthew 8:24, Mark 4:37, and Luke 8:23) of Jesus calming the Sea of Galilee “tempest,” and in the Old Testament in Psalm 11:6 as to judgment of the wicked by a “tempest.”) The thesis urged is that Measure for Measure is through-and-through a legalistic play (though, of course, not only that, as no Shakespeare play is one-dimensional). But, to support this thesis of a drama about the law, a definition of the term “rule of law” is needed. Accordingly, Parts II through V set out hallmarks of this term, drawing on Ancient, Medieval, and Modern sources, but relying most significantly on the work of the renowned British Professor A.V. Dicey (1835-1922) and U.S. Supreme Court Justice Anthony M. Kennedy (1936-). Part VI offers background about the play that help frame the thesis. Parts VII and VIII, respectively, apply those rule-of-law elements to the conduct (acts and omissions) of the leading, and several minor, characters of the play. Part IX proposes one character as candidate for “rule of law” heroine. Part X summarizes the rule-of-law themes in Measure for Measure that resonate for all time.
pdf
Applying Definitions of the "Rule of Law" to Shakespeare's Measure for Measure1.28 MBDownloadView
Open Access

Related links

Metrics

1 Record Views

Details

Logo image